The Coiled Altar: who failed which mechanic

Each of these charges the player who made the mistake, pull by pull. Counts follow Warcraft Logs': direct hits, not ticks (hits vs ticks).

A tank buster is judged on whether a defensive or an external was up on each hit, counting only defensives that tank is seen pressing in the report. Stacks are judged only where the guide states a limit; otherwise how long each tank held them is shown.

Here taking it, killing it or kicking it is the job, so each is credit to the player who did it, never a mark against anyone.

The log records the damage of these, not who was at fault: a raid-wide job, a placement or a puzzle it cannot see, or a guide that never says what failing looks like. They are shown as facts and nobody is charged.

• Virulent Mutation is checked on Mythic only: on an easier pull it never happens, so it is never judged there.
• Spirit Shield is checked on Mythic only: on an easier pull it never happens, so it is never judged there.
• Spiritcackle is checked on Heroic and Mythic only: on an easier pull it never happens, so it is never judged there.

• Guillotine needs at least 5 soakers, and Grim Guillotine (stage three) is a soak too: a short cast charges the players who should have been in it.
• Widow's Kiss and Death's Embrace: the axe explodes after it lands, and everyone within 50 yards is hit. Nobody is excused when the whole raid stayed in range: then everyone made the mistake, so the raid-wide baseline is switched off here.
• Soul Sever is a tank's cone: only non-tanks are charged, and it is measured on the cone itself, not the damage-over-time it leaves.
• Many of this fight's mechanics are about placement, which the log cannot judge: they are shown as facts.

• Dreadful Presence: Unavoidable damage — there is nothing the player could have done.
• Fangs of the Coiled Altar: Unavoidable damage — there is nothing the player could have done.
• Soulbound: A fight-wide timer, not something one player can act on.